The Restaurant Profit You're Throwing in the Garbage

Episode 603 • November 16, 2026 • 00:18:48
The Restaurant Profit You're Throwing in the Garbage
RESTAURANT STRATEGY
The Restaurant Profit You're Throwing in the Garbage

Nov 16 2026 | 00:18:48

/

Show Notes

#603 - The Restaurant Profit You're Throwing in the Garbage

BUILD A BETTER RESTAURANT: https://www.restaurantstrategypodcast.com/listeners


*****
 

This week's episode is brought to you by: AJINOMOTO
VISIT: https://ajinomotofoodservice.com/


*****

If your food cost percentage is consistently higher than it should be, this episode is for you. We're talking about the variance between theoretical food cost and actual food cost... and going over the five biggest culprits. 

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:00] I want you to imagine that you own a restaurant doing $2 million a year. I don't know, maybe you own a restaurant doing $2 million a year. So you don't have to get too creative here. But your food target, your food cost target is 30%. You've costed out all your recipes, you've negotiated with your vendors, you've reviewed your menu prices. And based on everything you've calculated, your food cost should be right at 30%. And then your bookkeeper sends over the monthly P and L and food cost is 35%. [00:00:28] That's five points over. Now, five percentage points might not sound like an enormous difference, but on $2 million in annual sales, that's $100,000. 100,000 bucks. And here is the actual frustrating part. You don't know where it went. See, you don't have $100,000 sitting in the walk in. You don't have $100,000 worth of invoices you can point to. You just know that somehow at some point, the cost of producing your menu is significantly higher than it should be. [00:00:58] So where's the money? Well, some of it might be sitting in the garbage. Some of it might be in your employees stomachs. Some of it might be going out the door in oversized portions. Some of it might be disappearing through poor inventory controls. And some of it might be the result of products you're purchasing but never properly tracking. So today we're going to talk about the difference between theoretical food cost and actual food costs. And more importantly, we're going to talk about how we close the gap. Because that's what I want you to understand. The food you buy isn't necessary necessarily. The food you sell and everything that happens between those two moments has a financial consequence, a six figure consequence. If it's five points, let's get into it. On today's episode of Restaurant Strategy. [00:01:42] There's an old saying that goes something like this. You'll only find three kinds of people in the world. Those who see, those who will never see, and those who can see when shown. This is Restaurant Strategy, a podcast with answers for anyone who's looking. [00:02:13] Hey everyone, thanks for tuning in. My name is Chip Close. This is the Restaurant Strategy podcast. We put out two episodes every single week. I put out free content everywhere on YouTube, Instagram, LinkedIn, TikTok. I put out this show again, two episodes a week. I take the stage and conventions, conferences, trade shows all over the country. I've written two books. The first one came out in 2023. The next one is coming out in January. More on that soon. I also run a coaching program. It's called the P3 mastermind. That right? So I got all this free content. But that coaching program is the single best way I know how to help independent restaurant owners increase the profitability of their restaurants. We help you make more so you can ultimately work less. If you want to learn more about that program, program. Rsprofit.com we bring in about a dozen people every single month. Naturally. My question is, why not you? If you struggle with profitability, you're stuck at 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10% and you're ready for 15, 20% or more. That's why you'd get in touch. We jump on a call with me or someone from my team. We answer a bunch of questions. We see if it's a good fit, if it's a good fit, we talk about next steps. Again, RSProphit.com as always, that link is in the show notes. [00:03:25] Ajinimoto is your answer to every busy dinner rush spent deep in the weeds. When hungry customers walk through your door, they expect good food, right? Good food that tastes homemade. But making every dish from scratch can cut into your profits. Certainly what we're talking about today, especially with the cost of ingredients and yes, the cost of labor. That's where Ajinimoto Foods comes in. Ajinimoto has a huge catalog of fast, easy to prep frozen Asian products that taste and look homemade. That includes classics like fried rice dumplings and onion rings and new trendy fusion plates like kimchi chicken pot stickers. See, choosing Ajinimoto is choosing over 100 years of proven expertise in the food service space. Choose to save time, choose to save money in your busy kitchen without compromising on the quality your customers have come to expect. Learn more about [email protected] and yes, you'll find that link in the show notes. [00:04:27] Okay, so I've been talking about it, teasing it out a little bit, but I wrote a book called the Restaurant Profit Playbook. It collects so many of the ideas, insights, playbooks, frameworks that I've developed over my career in this industry, right? It's called the Restaurant Profit Playbook. It comes out in January. [00:04:43] And in that book I talk about the distinction between theoretical food cost and actual food cost. Of course, it's something we've talked about before on this show. It's that important, right? It's one of the most important concepts to, you know, to understanding restaurant financial management. [00:04:57] So of course, what is it Right. Theoretical food cost is what your food cost should be based on your recipes and the items you've sold. But actual food cost is what your food really costs based on the inventory you've consumed throughout the period. And those are often very different numbers. And the difference, I think, tells a story. So let me use a simple example. Imagine you sell a cheeseburger for 20 bucks, and the ingredients cost six bucks. Meaning you got the beef, the bun, the cheese, lettuce, tomato sauce, you know, everything goes on it. All of that comes out to $6 in real time food cost. So that's 30%. Now, imagine you sell a hundred of those burgers based on your recipes. You should consume $600 worth of ingredients. That's theoretical cost. [00:05:45] But what if the actual amount of food consumed is $720? Well, now you've got a $120 discrepancy. Obviously, something happened. Maybe the cooks are using more beef than the recipe calls for. Maybe they're adding extra cheese. Or maybe ingredients are being wasted. Maybe employees are eating burgers that aren't being recorded. Maybe you're experiencing spoilage. Right. Maybe counts are inaccurate in inventory. [00:06:11] Whatever the cause, the bottom line is the numbers don't match. And here's the important thing to remember. If you only look at your recipe cost, you won't actually see the problem. And if you only look at your actual food cost percentage, you might know there's a problem without understanding actually what's causing it. So the reality is, you need both. Now, calculating actual food cost requires accurate inventory, meaning beginning inventory plus purchases minus ending inventory, that gives you the cost of goods consumed during the given period. Assuming the figures are recorded consistently and adjusted appropriately for transfers or any other special circumstances. But that's the number. And then divide that number by the relevant sales, and now you have your actual food cost percentage. Now, the calculation is simple, but the process requires discipline. [00:07:04] Because if your inventory counts are inaccurate, your food cost calculation is going to be inaccurate. And that brings us to my first recommendation. Take inventory consistently, correctly, and frequently enough to make useful decisions. In that book that's coming out the Restaurant Profit Playbook, I identify five major culprits behind actual food cost problems. I think they are portioning, theft, waste, spoilage, end discounts, and untracked comps. So let's go through them one at a time. First, portion control. This might be the simplest problem to actually understand. [00:07:41] Your recipe calls for 6 ounces of protein, but your cook consistently serves 7. [00:07:46] That's a 16 1/2% increase in the protein portion, a big deal. And if that protein is one of the most expensive ingredients on the plate, then it can have a meaningful impact on the profitability of the dish. [00:08:00] Now, the guest might be thrilled they're getting more food, but you're not charging them for it. And if that happens hundreds of times a week, I think you can see the costs add up. The question is, how do you fix it? You fix it through standardization, right? Portioning tools, scales, recipe cards, training, and yes, regular spot checking. Not because you want to make your portion stingy, but because you want them to be consistent. [00:08:26] So the guest, the guest who orders a steak on Tuesday should receive the same portion as the guest who orders it on Saturday. [00:08:34] Consistency is actually good for the guest, and it's good for profitability. [00:08:38] Second one I mentioned was theft. Now, I know it's an uncomfortable subject. Nobody wants to believe their employees are stealing. But I don't want you to assume that every discrepancy is theft. In fact, most inventory problems have multiple possible explanations. [00:08:54] But yeah, theft does happen. Food disappears, beverages disappear, products are consumed without being recorded. And restaurants need appropriate controls. That means accurate receiving, meaning secure storage, clear employee meal policies, proper POS procedures and regular inventory checks. I worked a lot in fine dining. We would do checks on. We would do inventory for proteins, proteins and produce every single night. [00:09:22] It also means obviously treating employees fairly, but also investigating discrepancies before making accusations. Because a culture of suspicion obviously isn't a substitute for a good control system. [00:09:35] The third one up is waste. This one is enormous. See, food gets prepared incorrectly or orders are entered incorrectly, ingredients are dropped, dishes are remade, products are over prepped. And all of those things, yes, they cost you money. [00:09:50] Now some waste is inevitable. Restaurants are complicated operations. Obviously mistakes happen. And you should know how much waste you're generating and why. [00:10:01] Which means I think you need a waste log. Just something simple, couple of clipboards just so you can understand what was wasted, how much of it was wasted. Why record it? Not to embarrass people, but just to keep track, to identify patterns. Because if you're throwing away the same product every single week, then obviously something needs to change. Maybe your prep pars are wrong. Maybe your forecast was inaccurate. Maybe the recipe is overly complicated. Maybe somebody just needs additional training. But without tracking, you're just guessing. [00:10:33] The fourth one up is spoilage. This is what happens when product goes bad before you even have the chance to use it. And spoilage is often a purchasing and inventory problem, meaning you bought too much or you stored it incorrectly, or you didn't properly rotate inventory, you didn't know what you already had, or you. They didn't have a plan to use the product before it expired. That's why proper receiving labeling, storage rotation and par levels manage. I know, sexy stuff. But it's important because every dollar of spoiled product is a dollar you spent without generating revenue. And the fifth one, the last one I talked about, was discounts and untracked comps. And here's where we need to be precise. A properly recorded discount doesn't physically increase the cost of the ingredients used, but it can increase food cost as a percentage of net sales because you're generating less revenue from the same product. [00:11:27] And unrecorded comps can create discrepancies between expected and actual consumption. So you need clear policies. What can be comped, who can authorize it, how should it be entered, and how do you review those transactions? Because if food leaves the kitchen without being properly accounted for, well, then you lose visibility into the entire operation. [00:11:49] Now, let's take a second to talk about purchasing because this is another area where restaurants I see getting into trouble. A lot of owners will order food based on what they think they need or what the chef says they need, or just what they bought last week. But I want you to connect purchasing to expected sales. We do this in the P3 mastermind. Forecasting and budgeting is one of the key the foundations of the program. So we have a really great system for helping you do it, but it's crazy crucial. Let's say you're forecasting $40,000 in weekly sales, and your food sales are expected to be $25,000. If your target food food cost is 30%, your expected food consumption budget is $7,500. Now, that doesn't automatically mean you should purchase $7,500 of food, because purchasing and consumption are not the same thing. Because you may already have inventory on hand, you may need to replenish stock, you may have inventory you intend to use down, but the consumption budget gives you a starting point at the very least. And from there, yeah, you can build a purchasing plan based on inventory levels and expected demand. And this is where the declining budget becomes useful. Do you guys use this? We use this all the time. I demand, I require Everybody in the P3 mastermind to use it. In fact, everybody gets the same tool. You establish the amount you can afford to spend, then you subtract purchases as they're made in real time, daily and every day. You monitor what's remaining instead of Waiting until the end of the month to discover that, oh man, we overspent. You manage the budget throughout the period. Now, here's the key. The purchasing budget needs to reflect reality. If sales change, you may need to adjust. If inventory is unusually high, you may need to buy less. If you're prepping for a major event, you may need to plan differently. But the discipline of budgeting before you purchase is so incredibly powerful. Why? Because it forces you to connect decisions to the financial results you're trying to hit. [00:13:50] Now, I want to address an important misconception. Inventory isn't simply an accounting exercise. I believe it's a management tool. Because when you take inventory consistently, you begin to understand the flow of product through your restaurant. You know what you have, you know what you're purchasing, what you're using, and you begin identifying discrepancies. Now, I'm not suggesting that every restaurant needs to count every single ingredient every single day. I think that's probably unnecessary for most of you. [00:14:19] But I do want you to establish a consistent inventory schedule. And I want you to pay special attention to high value products, meaning proteins, seafood, premium spirits, wine, anything that represents what we call a meaningful financial risk. You might count certain products daily, others weekly, and others on a longer schedule. The right approach depends on your operation. Whatever you do, try to set up some consistency. Use the same counting methods, the same units, train the people who are responsible and investigate unusual changes. Because the objective isn't simply to produce a food cost percentage. The objective is to understand why that percentage is what it is, and then hopefully you can do something about it. So we keep talking about this $10,000, right? Let's put some numbers on this. Imagine your restaurant generates a million dollars in annual food sales, and your actual food cost is 33%. But based on your recipes and your sales mix, your theoretical food cost is 31%. [00:15:21] That's a two point gap. Doesn't sound like much. It's $20,000. Now, not all of that gap is necessarily recoverable. I get it. There may be normal yield differences, counting errors, or other factors that just simply need to be rec. [00:15:34] But suppose you can recover half of it, just one percentage point. That's your $10,000. That's your opportunity. So here's your assignment. For the next 30 days, I want you to focus on three things. First, make sure your inventory counts are accurate. [00:15:50] Second, start tracking waste consistently. [00:15:54] And third, choose your 10 highest volume or highest cost menu items and check whether actual portions match the actual recipes. [00:16:04] You're not going to try to Fix everything. Just find the biggest discrepancy, investigate the cause, and make one operational change. [00:16:13] And then, as always, measure the result. [00:16:16] I want you to remember, when food cost is too high, a lot of restaurant owners immediately start thinking about raising prices or renegotiating with vendors or finding cheaper ingredients. And those are all appropriate strategies. There's a time and a place. But. But before you change what you're charging or what you're buying, I want you to understand what's happening to the food you already purchase. Because the problem might not be the price of chicken. It might be the amount of chicken you're serving. It might not be the price of produce, it might be the amount of produce you're throwing away, it might not be the vendor. It might just simply be the lack of inventory controls. And the beautiful thing about fixing these problems is, is that you're not asking your customers to spend more. You're simply doing a better job managing the resources you already have. [00:17:04] So stop looking exclusively at the cost of the food you're buying. Start looking at what happens when that food arrives. [00:17:12] Because some of the easiest profit you'll ever find might already be sitting inside your restaurant, or worse, more likely, in the garbage. [00:17:21] Listen, I'm Chip Close. This is the Restaurant Strategy Podcast. I appreciate you making this show part of your week. Friendly reminder, if you get any kind of value from this show, please go to Apple Podcasts. Leave us a five star rating and review. Just let other people know what you get out of it. If you want to learn more about working with me directly, go to RSProphit.com that link you will find in the show notes. Thank you very much guys and I will see you next time. [00:17:47] Sam. [00:18:15] Sa.

Other Episodes

Episode 369

August 19, 2024 • 00:32:34
Episode Cover

FIXING RESTAURANTS (PART 6) - Evolution

#369 - FIXING RESTAURANTS (PART 6) - Evolution ***** This week's episode is brought to you by: KICKFIN Thousands of restaurants across the country...

Listen

Episode 75

August 17, 2020 • 00:34:28
Episode Cover

Step-by-Step Guide to Creating a Marketing Plan That Works

#75 - Step-by-Step Guide to Creating a Marketing Plan That Works This is a big one... I'm sharing my Marketing Plan outline and walking...

Listen

Episode 447

May 19, 2025 • 00:23:45
Episode Cover

Why You MUST Reverse Engineer for Profit (ENCORE)

#447 - Why You MUST Reverse Engineer for Profit (ENCORE) ***** This week's episode is brought to you by: TORK  TORK understands that expectations...

Listen